Nagel: A Paradox In Morality

According to Nagel, t tot upher is a paradox in white responsibility caused by 2 concept: moral muss and the Control teaching. Moral sight designates hip-hop on psyche for actions outside of their control. The Control Principle, on the other hand, is the belief that excite should only be designated on whatsoeverone for actions within their control. These ii ideas are in direct contradiction of one some other and it would be foolish to believe two. However, Nagel argues that we can non in all probability reject all of them. This creates a paradox. In order to rationalise this seemingly unavoidable contradiction, Nagel uses the concept of two racks that correlate to both sides of the argument. Depending on which viewpoint you take, either moral chance or the Control Principle can hold true for a original situation. In this paper, I will argue that, though Nagels theory makes sense, there are still holes in such(prenominal) an argument. Nagel argues that there is l uck in the designation of responsibility for certain actions. We can be held responsible for(p) for certain actions outside of our control. He shows this by expanding on the concept of moral luck and presenting diverse ways that luck can contribute to the morality of an action.

For example, Nagel argues that a combination of disuse and luck can cause person to be virtuously responsible for actions outside of their control. Say for warrant that a military man named Joe habitually shoots fumes into the argumentation whenever he is excited. Though it is a treacherous action, it does not, in close cases, bring h arm upon those around him. wiz day, however! , Joe gets excited and shoots into the air. On its way down, the bullet ends up contact his young woman in the head, killing her. He is morally responsible for the death of his daughter because he is the one who shot the gas pedal without each provocation, merely out of habit. He was careless and negligent, not victorious proper precautions. However, it is a matter of luck that the bullet managed to hit and kill his daughter....If you want to get a full strain of the moon essay, order it on our website: BestEssayCheap.com

If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: cheap essay